Tales from the Universe
Everyone in Bellweather knows you do not throw things into Mercy Lake.
Not because of littering.
Although the town council would like to emphasize that littering is also prohibited.
You do not throw things into Mercy Lake because eventually—
the lake gives them back.
Fourteen-year-old Mara Vale learns this when she is eight.
She is standing on the dock with her older brother, Jonah.
He has just taught her how to skip stones.
Mara finds a particularly good one.
Flat.
Black.
Almost perfectly round.
She throws.
Five skips.
Jonah whistles.
“Nice.”
The stone sinks.
The following morning, Mara finds it on her pillow.
Wet.
Her mother believes Jonah put it there.
Jonah denies it.
Mara believes Jonah.
Mostly because he would have bragged.
She throws the stone back.
Next morning:
Kitchen table.
Wet.
She throws it farther.
Bathroom sink.
Wet.
Jonah takes her out in a canoe and drops it into the deepest part of Mercy Lake.
The next morning it is inside his shoe.
Jonah stares at it.
“Okay.”
Mara smiles.
“Lake rock.”
“Absolutely not.”
“Lake rock.”
They keep it.
Problem solved.
As Mara grows older, she learns everyone has a Mercy Lake story.
Mrs. Wren threw away her wedding ring after her divorce.
It appeared in her mailbox three days later.
Mr. Bell dumped an old bicycle from the bridge when he was sixteen.
Thirty years later, after the lake flooded, the bicycle appeared in his backyard.
A fisherman dropped his father’s pocketknife overboard.
It returned inside a fish.
Nobody knows how.
Nobody investigates anymore.
The town has simply developed rules.
Do not dump garbage.
Do not scatter ashes.
Do not throw away anything you genuinely want gone.
Especially letters.
Mara asks why letters are different.
Her grandmother says:
“People write things they aren’t ready to say.”
This explains nothing.
Which means Mara remembers it.
The summer Mara turns fourteen, her father leaves.
Not disappears.
Leaves.
There is an important difference.
He packs two suitcases.
He tells Mara and Jonah that he loves them.
He tells their mother he needs time.
He rents an apartment in Glass Harbor.
Then he becomes increasingly difficult to reach.
Calls become texts.
Texts become:
Sorry, busy. Tomorrow?
Tomorrow becomes next week.
Next week becomes nothing.
Mara does not know what to call this.
Everyone around her supplies words.
Separation.
Space.
Transition.
Family difficulty.
Her grandmother says:
“He’s confused.”
Jonah says:
“He’s selfish.”
Their mother says:
“Your relationship with your father is between you and him.”
Mara hates all of these explanations.
She wants one that makes the thing hurt correctly.
She writes her father a letter.
Six pages.
She tells him everything.
That she is angry.
That she misses him.
That she hates checking her phone.
That she hates herself for checking.
That she hates how happy she gets when he finally answers.
That she wants him to come home.
That she doesn’t.
That she wants him to explain.
That she doesn’t believe any explanation will be enough.
She finishes at 1:13 in the morning.
Reads it.
Then feels humiliated.
Too much.
Too needy.
Too angry.
Too honest.
She tears it into pieces.
Walks to Mercy Lake.
Throws them in.
The pieces float beneath the moon.
Then disappear.
Mara goes home.
The next morning the letter is on her desk.
Whole.
Not taped.
Not repaired.
Whole.
Six pages.
Her handwriting.
Water dripping onto the floor.
Mara stares at it.
“No.”
She tears it again.
Burns the pieces.
Drops the ashes into the lake.
The following morning:
Six pages.
Wet.
She shreds them.
Lake.
Returns.
She writes:
I DON’T MEAN THIS ANYMORE
across every page.
Lake.
Returns without the new writing.
That frightens her.
Jonah finds her fourth attempt.
“You threw something in Mercy.”
“Go away.”
He sees the letter.
“Oh.”
“GO AWAY.”
He does.
Ten minutes later he returns with two sodas.
He places one beside her.
Does not speak.
Mara eventually says:
“I don’t want it.”
“The letter?”
“Yes.”
“Then stop throwing it away.”
She looks at him.
“That doesn’t make sense.”
“Seems like throwing it away is how you order another one.”
Despite herself, Mara laughs.
Then cries.
Jonah remains.
They investigate the lake.
Not because Mara thinks understanding it will solve her father.
Because investigation is easier.
They collect stories.
Returned objects fall into strange categories.
Things lost accidentally sometimes return.
Things discarded casually usually don’t.
Garbage does not reappear.
Broken furniture stays gone.
A soda can thrown into the lake remains litter.
But objects carrying some unresolved importance often return.
Wedding rings.
Photographs.
Letters.
Childhood toys.
A military medal.
An unopened college acceptance letter.
A man’s twenty-year sobriety chip that he threw away after drinking again.
That one returned every morning for three months.
Mara asks him what finally stopped it.
“I put it in a drawer.”
“You didn’t get sober?”
“Not then.”
“So why did the lake stop?”
He shrugs.
“Maybe it didn’t need me to fix anything.”
“What did it need?”
“For me to stop pretending it hadn’t happened.”
Mara writes that down.
Then they find exceptions.
Mrs. Clay threw her husband’s wedding ring into Mercy Lake after he died.
Never returned.
A teenager threw away photographs of an abusive boyfriend.
Never returned.
A veteran threw his uniform into the lake.
Never returned.
So the rule cannot simply be:
Important things come back.
Sometimes important things leave.
Mara changes her theory.
Things you shouldn’t throw away come back.
Jonah immediately asks:
“According to who?”
She crosses it out.
Good question.
Grandma Vale has another theory.
“The lake returns unfinished things.”
Mara likes this better.
Until Jonah asks:
“What does unfinished mean?”
Grandma tells him to eat his pie.
They test it.
Jonah writes:
I HAVE ALWAYS HATED YOUR HAIR
on paper.
Throws it in.
Nothing.
Mara writes:
I BROKE YOUR HEADPHONES IN 2021 AND BLAMED THE CAT.
Lake.
The note returns the following morning.
Jonah looks at her.
“You WHAT?”
Mara grabs the note.
“Scientific progress.”
“The cat was punished.”
“The cat did not understand.”
“I apologized to him.”
“Then everybody grew.”
Jonah chases her around the house.
The experiment nevertheless supports Grandma’s theory.
Maybe.
Mara eventually notices the real problem.
Everyone talks about the returned objects.
Nobody talks about what happened after.
She goes back through the stories.
Mrs. Wren’s wedding ring returned.
She did not reconcile with her husband.
She sold it.
It never returned.
The sobriety chip returned.
The man eventually put it in a drawer.
It stopped.
A woman received an old photograph six times.
Eventually she mailed it to her sister.
Gone.
A boy’s college letter returned.
He finally opened it.
Afterward he threw it into the lake.
It stayed gone.
The lake does not appear to demand a particular outcome.
It demands something more annoying.
Engagement.
Mara hates this theory.
Because it means the letter does not necessarily want to be sent.
That would be easier.
SEND THE LETTER.
Clear quest objective.
But maybe she could send it.
Or rewrite it.
Or keep it.
Or talk to her father.
Or decide not to.
The lake does not tell her.
It merely refuses to let disposal impersonate resolution.
Then her father calls.
After twenty-three days.
“Hey, bug.”
Mara almost hangs up.
He has called her that since she was little.
She hates how quickly hearing it changes her.
“Hi.”
“Sorry I’ve been hard to reach.”
She says nothing.
“Work has been crazy.”
Still nothing.
“I’ve had a lot going on.”
Mara looks at the six-page letter.
There are dozens of things she could say.
Instead:
“I wrote you something.”
“Oh?”
“I don’t know if I want you to read it.”
“Okay.”
That surprises her.
“I thought you’d ask.”
“I can.”
“No.”
“Okay.”
Silence.
Then her father says:
“Are you angry with me?”
Mara nearly laughs.
How could he not know?
Then she realizes he may genuinely not know how much.
“Yes.”
Another silence.
“How angry?”
Mara looks at the letter.
“Six pages.”
Her father laughs once.
Then realizes she isn’t joking.
“Oh.”
“Yeah.”
For the first time in months, they have an actual conversation.
Not a good one.
An actual one.
Those are different.
Mara does not send the letter.
After the call, she reads it again.
Some parts still feel true.
Some don’t.
Some were true only at 1:13 that particular morning.
She keeps it in her desk.
Weeks pass.
It dries.
The pages wrinkle.
Her father does not magically become reliable.
Sometimes he calls.
Sometimes he doesn’t.
Mara learns to tell him when she is angry instead of waiting for him to notice.
Sometimes he listens.
Sometimes he becomes defensive.
Nothing resolves cleanly.
That bothers her less than it used to.
Six months later, Mara takes the letter back to Mercy Lake.
Jonah comes.
“You sure?”
“No.”
“Good start.”
She folds the pages.
Does not tear them.
Places them on the water.
They float.
Slowly drift away.
Then sink.
Next morning—
nothing.
Mara checks her desk.
Her pillow.
Kitchen table.
Jonah’s shoes.
Nothing.
The letter is gone.
She feels relieved.
Then unexpectedly sad.
Both are allowed.
Years later, Mara becomes the person children ask about Mercy Lake.
Mostly because she wrote down more stories than anyone else.
They want rules.
“What does the lake return?”
“I don’t know.”
“How does it choose?”
“I don’t know.”
“Is it magic?”
“I don’t know.”
This disappoints them.
So she gives them the best rule she has:
“If something comes back, don’t immediately throw it away again.”
“What should I do with it?”
“Look at it.”
“And then?”
“Depends what it is.”
Children hate answers like this.
Adults do too.
The town eventually puts a sign beside the lake.
The council proposes:
NO DUMPING.
Mara supports this.
Then somebody adds:
THE LAKE RETURNS WHAT YOU ARE NOT READY TO RELEASE.
Mara objects.
“How do we know that?”
Nobody can answer.
They change it.
The final sign reads:
PLEASE DO NOT THROW OBJECTS INTO MERCY LAKE.
IF SOMETHING RETURNS, CONSIDER WHY IT MATTERS BEFORE DISCARDING IT AGAIN.
Much better.
One autumn evening, Mara sits beside the water.
A little girl walks onto the dock.
She carries a stuffed rabbit.
Old.
One ear missing.
She holds it over the water.
Mara watches.
The girl notices her.
“Will it come back?”
“Maybe.”
“I don’t want it anymore.”
Mara nods.
“Okay.”
The girl hesitates.
“My mom gave it to me.”
Mara waits.
“She died.”
There it is.
Not an answer.
Context.
Mara moves over on the bench.
The girl sits.
For several minutes neither speaks.
Eventually the girl puts the rabbit in her backpack.
Maybe she will throw it away tomorrow.
Maybe in ten years.
Maybe never.
Mercy Lake does not decide.
That is something people often misunderstand about letting go.
Release cannot always be commanded.
Neither can keeping.
Sometimes an object is only an object.
Sometimes it is carrying a conversation you have not finished having with yourself.
And sometimes the first sign that something is not gone—
is that you keep having to throw it away.
Leave a Reply