Tales from the Universe
Moral Dilemma: If painful memories are harming your ability to live in the present, but those same memories contain love, identity, warning, and hard-earned wisdom, how much of your past can you safely release before healing becomes another kind of disappearance?
The Memory House had excellent reviews.
This bothered Mara.
Places involving memory removal should not have reviews.
Certainly not cheerful ones.
FIVE STARS. SLEPT THROUGH THE NIGHT FOR THE FIRST TIME IN TWELVE YEARS.
PROFESSIONAL STAFF. CLEAN FACILITY.
WOULD FORGET AGAIN.
Mara stared at that one.
“That’s funny.”
Her brother Tovin didn’t laugh.
They had come for him.
Mostly.
Tovin remembered everything.
Not literally.
He forgot birthdays.
Keys.
Names.
Where he put his shoes.
But certain things?
Perfectly.
Their father’s voice when angry.
The smell of the hallway outside their childhood bedroom.
Which floorboards creaked.
How many steps from the kitchen to the back door.
The exact sound of a glass being placed on a table before an argument began.
His body had archived details his mind desperately wanted to delete.
Their father had been dead nine years.
Tovin still listened for him.
Mara remembered too.
Differently.
She remembered hiding with Tovin.
Passing notes beneath the bedroom door.
Making each other laugh silently.
She remembered their mother singing while washing dishes.
Summer afternoons.
A broken bicycle they repaired badly.
Their father teaching them cards on one of his good days.
The past was not one thing.
That was the problem.
Doctor Vale greeted them.
“Memory removal is an inaccurate term.”
Tovin sighed.
“What do you call it?”
“Memory attenuation.”
“That sounds expensive.”
“It is.”
Mara smiled.
Tovin didn’t.
Vale explained.
They did not erase events.
Not usually.
They weakened pathways.
Sensory intensity.
Emotional response.
Automatic associations.
“You’ll remember what happened.”
Vale tapped the diagram.
“But it will feel more like something that happened in the past.”
Tovin stared.
“That sounds wonderful.”
Mara felt afraid.
“What can go wrong?” she asked.
Vale smiled.
“Excellent.”
Tovin looked at her.
“What?”
“Most people ask how soon we can start.”
Memory was interconnected.
Remove one association, neighboring memories could weaken.
Smell of whiskey linked to father.
Also grandfather.
Also Tovin’s first job at a tavern.
Also the night Mara graduated.
You could not always pull one thread without disturbing others.
“How much gets lost?”
“Usually very little.”
“Usually?”
“Yes.”
Tovin leaned forward.
“Do it.”
Mara said:
“Wait.”
He looked at her.
“No.”
“Tovin.”
“No.”
He turned to Vale.
“When?”
First session.
The hallway.
Vale had Tovin recall it.
Heart rate increased.
Hands shook.
Then treatment.
Light.
Sound.
A spell woven through machinery.
Very modern magic.
Very expensive.
Afterward Vale asked:
“Picture the hallway.”
Tovin did.
Nothing happened.
He began laughing.
Then crying.
Mara had never seen relief look so much like grief.
“It’s just a hallway.”
Tovin kept saying it.
“It’s just a hallway.”
Mara held him.
“Yes.”
He slept ten hours.
First time in years.
The treatment worked.
Second session.
The sound of glass on wood.
Third.
His father’s footsteps.
Fourth.
The smell of whiskey.
Tovin changed.
He relaxed.
Gained weight.
Started dating.
Stopped checking locks three times.
Mara watched her brother return.
Or perhaps arrive.
She wasn’t sure.
Then he forgot the card game.
They were visiting their mother.
She brought out the old deck.
“Remember King’s Lantern?”
Tovin stared.
“No.”
Mara laughed.
“You cheated constantly.”
“What game?”
Their mother explained.
Tovin shook his head.
“Never played.”
Mara stopped smiling.
Their father had taught them.
Whiskey on the table.
Cards.
Good night.
One of the good ones.
The smell had been treated.
The footsteps.
The room.
The father’s voice.
Somewhere among the pathways, King’s Lantern had dimmed too.
Tovin shrugged.
“So?”
Mara stared.
“You loved that game.”
“Apparently.”
“Doesn’t that bother you?”
“No.”
That bothered her more.
She confronted Vale.
“You said neighboring memories might weaken.”
“Yes.”
“He lost an entire memory.”
“Yes.”
“You said very little.”
“One memory is very little.”
“Not if it’s yours.”
Vale became quiet.
“Correct.”
Tovin wanted to continue.
Mara wanted him to stop.
They argued.
“You’re losing things.”
“I’m sleeping.”
“You forgot Dad teaching us cards.”
“Good.”
Mara recoiled.
Tovin saw.
“What?”
“Nothing.”
“No. Say it.”
“He wasn’t always terrible.”
Tovin laughed.
“Here we go.”
“What does that mean?”
“You need him complicated.”
“He was complicated.”
“I need him gone.”
Silence.
Mara understood.
She also hated it.
For her, remembering their father’s good moments prevented the bad ones from swallowing childhood whole.
For Tovin, the good memories kept reopening the door.
Same history.
Different survival strategy.
“You’re going to erase him.”
“Yes.”
“He’s part of you.”
“That is exactly what I am trying to change.”
Tovin continued.
His father’s face weakened.
Not disappeared.
Became vague.
Voice faded.
Specific arguments became summaries.
“I know he used to yell.”
Rather than hearing the yelling.
That distinction transformed Tovin’s life.
He became happier.
Clearly.
Undeniably.
Mara could not argue with the evidence.
Then their mother died.
At the funeral, Mara told a story.
Their mother singing while washing dishes.
Tovin smiled politely.
Afterward:
“What song?”
Mara stared.
“You know.”
“No.”
“The washing song.”
Nothing.
Their mother had sung it during arguments.
Trying to cover the sound.
The memory had been tangled with their father.
Gone.
Mara went home and screamed into a pillow.
Tovin found her.
“You think I killed them.”
“What?”
“In my head.”
“No.”
“You do.”
Mara sat up.
“I think you’re losing us.”
“I am right here.”
“For now.”
Tovin became angry.
“So what do you want?”
“I don’t know!”
“That’s the first honest thing you’ve said.”
Mara cried.
“I remember you holding my hand under the blanket.”
Tovin froze.
“When?”
“You don’t remember?”
Silence.
“You would squeeze twice when Dad started yelling.”
Tovin looked down.
“No.”
“Twice meant I’m here.”
Nothing.
Mara’s face broke.
“You don’t remember.”
“No.”
Tovin sat beside her.
For a long time.
Then squeezed her hand.
Twice.
Mara sobbed.
“That doesn’t count.”
“I know.”
He squeezed again.
“I’m here now.”
Treatment stopped.
Not permanently.
Paused.
For a year.
Tovin learned other ways to carry memory.
Therapy.
Breathing.
Writing.
Medication for sleep for a while.
Walking.
Talking to Mara when he actually wanted to.
Not talking when he didn’t.
Ordinary tools.
Less miraculous.
Slower.
Some memories returned slightly.
King’s Lantern did not.
The washing song did.
One afternoon Tovin began humming it while cooking.
He stopped.
Mara heard from the other room.
Neither said anything.
Years later, Tovin returned to the Memory House.
Mara came.
Not because he needed permission.
Because he asked.
One memory remained unbearable.
The last night with their father.
Tovin had been fifteen.
Their father was drunk.
Tovin finally fought back.
Hit him.
Hard.
Their father fell.
For years Tovin believed he might have killed him.
He hadn’t.
But the moment remained.
Not father’s violence.
Tovin’s.
“I want this one attenuated.”
Mara asked:
“Why?”
“Because I understand it.”
“That sounds like a reason to keep it.”
“I understand fire too.”
He smiled sadly.
“I don’t need to burn every night to remember it’s hot.”
Mara nodded.
That made sense.
Painfully.
Doctor Vale was older.
Same terrible terminology.
He prepared the treatment.
Before beginning, Tovin wrote something.
Mara asked:
“What?”
“A note.”
“To yourself?”
“Yes.”
Afterward, the memory remained.
But distant.
Fifteen-year-old Tovin swung.
Father fell.
Tovin knew.
No adrenaline.
No nausea.
No immediate shame.
History.
He opened the note.
It read:
YOU HIT HIM.
Then:
YOU WERE AFRAID.
Then:
YOU COULD HAVE HURT HIM BADLY.
Then:
YOU LEARNED FROM THIS.
Then:
YOU ARE NOT REQUIRED TO KEEP BLEEDING IN ORDER TO PROVE THAT YOU REMEMBER.
Tovin read it twice.
Folded it.
Put it in his pocket.
Years passed.
Mara eventually chose treatment too.
One memory.
Different one.
She never told Tovin which.
He never asked.
That was part of what they had learned.
When they were old, they played cards.
Tovin still didn’t remember King’s Lantern.
So Mara taught him.
He was terrible.
Then suspiciously good.
“You’re cheating.”
“I don’t even know the rules.”
“You’re cheating instinctively.”
“Perhaps Father taught me.”
Mara stopped.
Tovin smiled.
It didn’t hurt.
Not much.
They played.
At some point Tovin reached across the table.
Squeezed Mara’s hand twice.
She looked up.
“You remember?”
“No.”
He smiled.
“But I know what it means.”
That became enough.
Not because the missing memory didn’t matter.
It did.
Something had been lost.
Something else had been saved.
There was no arithmetic capable of proving the exchange correct.
When the Memory House asked Tovin for a testimonial, he wrote:
FOUR STARS.
Mara laughed.
“Why four?”
“They lost King’s Lantern.”
“You hated King’s Lantern.”
“I apparently loved it.”
“Fair.”
Below the rating he wrote:
Forgetting is not the opposite of healing.
Then crossed it out.
Too certain.
He tried again.
Remembering is not the same thing as honoring.
Crossed that out too.
Finally:
Some memories are maps.
Some are wounds.
Most are both.
Be careful what you throw away.
Be equally careful what you insist on carrying forever.
He left it there.
Five sentences.
No conclusion.
For once, Tovin thought that was enough.
Leave a Reply