Tales from the Universe
Moral Dilemma: When knowledge is freely given to you by someone from another tradition, does receiving it make it yours to use however you wish—or do some gifts carry responsibilities that ownership cannot erase?
Eren learned the spell from a woman who repeatedly told him it was not a spell.
“It’s a breathing practice.”
“That’s what a spell is.”
“No.”
“Breath, intention, result.”
“That does not make everything a spell.”
Eren considered.
“Cooking.”
“Not a spell.”
“Blacksmithing.”
“No.”
“Music.”
“No.”
“Conversation.”
“Absolutely not.”
Eren smiled.
“You’re very narrow-minded about magic.”
The woman threw a sandal at him.
Her name was Ama.
Eren met her while traveling through the southern islands.
He had gone there to study medicinal plants.
This was the official reason.
The real reason was that his engagement had ended and every street in his home city contained something that reminded him of Lessa.
He wanted geography to do what courage had not.
Ama recognized this immediately.
“You came very far to avoid being sad.”
Eren stared.
“We met yesterday.”
“You talk too much.”
Ama was a healer.
Not the mystical sort travelers wrote embarrassing books about.
She treated burns.
Set bones.
Delivered babies.
Made terrible tea.
Knew exactly which plants caused diarrhea and occasionally threatened rude people with this information.
Eren liked her enormously.
The breathing practice came after he panicked during a storm.
They were sheltering inside a fishing hut.
Wind hammered the walls.
Eren’s chest tightened.
His hands went numb.
He could not breathe properly.
Ama sat in front of him.
“Look.”
He couldn’t.
She slapped the floor.
“Eren.”
He looked.
“Breathe when I breathe.”
She inhaled.
Slow.
Held.
Exhaled longer.
Again.
Again.
Eren followed.
His body gradually returned.
“What was that?”
“Breathing.”
“No.”
“Yes.”
“You changed something.”
“Yes.”
“With breathing.”
“Yes.”
“Spell.”
Ama reached for the sandal.
He practiced.
It worked.
Not always.
Not perfectly.
But enough.
Before difficult conversations.
During storms.
When memories of Lessa arrived unexpectedly.
When his thoughts became too fast.
Breath.
Pause.
Return.
Eren wrote the pattern in his notebook.
Ama saw him.
“What are you doing?”
“Recording it.”
“Why?”
“So I remember.”
She nodded.
“Good.”
When Eren returned home, he taught it to his brother.
Then a friend.
Then a patient at the herb shop where he worked.
The patient returned a week later.
“That breathing thing helped.”
Eren felt wonderful.
“Really?”
“Yes.”
“Want another?”
“There are more?”
Eren had learned several from Ama.
He taught another.
Soon people began asking for him.
“The breathing man.”
He hated the name.
Then secretly liked it.
He began offering evening classes.
Free.
At first.
A student asked:
“Where does this come from?”
Eren answered:
“The southern islands.”
That sounded vague.
“Which island?”
Eren named it.
“What is the practice called?”
Eren hesitated.
Ama had used a word.
He could not pronounce it correctly.
So he said:
“I call it Returning Breath.”
The student nodded.
Eren felt something shift.
Tiny.
He ignored it.
Classes grew.
Someone suggested charging.
“People value what they pay for.”
Eren disliked the sentence.
Then rent increased.
He charged a small fee.
Nobody objected.
He developed a system.
Five breaths.
Then seven.
He combined Ama’s practices with techniques from other teachers.
Added visualization.
Movement.
Names.
Returning Breath.
Stone Breath.
Lantern Breath.
People loved the names.
Eren published a booklet.
It sold well.
Three years later, Ama arrived at his class.
Eren nearly dropped his cup.
She stood at the back.
Older.
Same expression.
He ran to embrace her.
She hugged him.
Then pinched his ear.
“Ow.”
“You made breathing complicated.”
Eren showed her everything.
The classes.
Book.
Students.
Testimonials.
People whose panic had improved.
People who slept better.
A soldier who used the breathing to stop himself striking his son during an argument.
Ama listened.
Eren waited for approval.
It did not arrive.
Finally she held up the book.
“Why is your name here?”
“I wrote it.”
“You wrote breathing?”
“No.”
“You wrote this practice?”
“I adapted it.”
“From what?”
“From what you taught me.”
“Where is my name?”
Eren stopped.
There was a short acknowledgment.
Near the back.
Inspired in part by traditional southern breathing methods.
He suddenly hated the sentence.
“You gave it to me.”
“Yes.”
“You told me to practice.”
“Yes.”
“I used it to help people.”
“Yes.”
“Then what did I do wrong?”
Ama looked at him.
“I don’t know yet.”
That surprised him.
She attended classes for a month.
Sometimes she approved.
Sometimes she laughed.
Sometimes she became angry.
One evening Eren taught Lantern Breath.
Ama interrupted.
“That is not what I taught you.”
“I changed it.”
“I know.”
“It works better for some people.”
“Maybe.”
“Then what’s wrong?”
Ama thought.
“Nothing.”
Eren blinked.
“Nothing?”
“That change is good.”
He became irritated.
“You are making this extremely difficult.”
“Yes.”
Another practice bothered her.
Eren had turned a ceremonial breathing sequence into a two-minute exercise for calming nerves.
Ama stopped him.
“No.”
“Why?”
“That one isn’t for this.”
“It works.”
“I know.”
“Then?”
She searched for words.
“In my village, that breath is used when preparing the dead.”
The room became silent.
Eren stared.
“You never told me.”
“You never asked.”
“How would I know to ask?”
Ama nodded.
“Exactly.”
That night they argued.
“You taught me without explaining any of this.”
“I taught you what you needed.”
“Then you expected me to know invisible rules.”
“No.”
“What did you expect?”
“That you would know you didn’t know everything.”
That landed.
Eren stopped teaching for several weeks.
Students complained.
Some depended on the practice.
One said:
“I don’t care where it came from. It helps me.”
Eren understood.
Another said:
“If Ama gave it to you, it’s yours.”
He understood that too.
Then a scholar accused Eren publicly of stealing southern medicine.
Eren became defensive.
Ama became furious.
At the scholar.
“You weren’t there.”
The scholar blinked.
“He appropriated—”
“I taught him.”
“That doesn’t necessarily—”
Ama pointed a finger.
“Do not explain my own gift to me.”
Eren enjoyed this considerably more than he should have.
Later he asked:
“So I’m not stealing?”
Ama sighed.
“You want a clean answer.”
“Yes.”
“No.”
“That’s not—”
“Exactly.”
They rebuilt the classes together.
Not by returning everything to its original form.
Ama refused that too.
“Traditions change.”
“Then adaptation is fine?”
“Sometimes.”
“Could you please stop saying sometimes?”
“No.”
They separated the practices.
Some Ama was comfortable sharing publicly.
Some she said belonged within specific ceremonies.
Those Eren removed.
Some of Eren’s inventions were genuinely his.
They labeled them accordingly.
Some were mixtures.
They said so.
The new book listed teachers.
Places.
Sources.
Uncertainties.
Where Eren did not know something, he wrote:
I DON’T KNOW.
His publisher hated this.
Readers surprisingly did not.
Then came the money.
Eren had earned a substantial amount.
He offered half to Ama.
She refused.
“Why?”
“I don’t want it.”
“Then what do I do?”
“Something useful.”
“That is not specific.”
“Good.”
They eventually created a fund for healers on the island.
Ama insisted it not be charity.
“What is it?”
“Payment.”
“For what?”
She held up Eren’s book.
“Apparently we have been supplying your business.”
He laughed.
“Fair.”
Years later, Eren became well known.
People sometimes called Returning Breath Eren’s Method.
Whenever this happened within earshot, he corrected them.
Not dramatically.
“Part of it is mine.”
Then he explained.
Some listeners cared.
Some didn’t.
He explained anyway.
A student once asked Ama:
“Do you regret teaching him?”
She looked across the room.
Eren was demonstrating a breathing pattern to twelve people.
He was doing it slightly wrong.
Ama smiled.
“No.”
“Even after everything?”
“Especially after everything.”
The student looked confused.
Ama continued.
“A gift that can never change isn’t alive.”
“So he can do whatever he wants with it?”
“No.”
“Then what’s the rule?”
Ama laughed.
“You people love rules.”
She called Eren over.
“What is the rule?”
He knew this was a trap.
“Don’t be an idiot?”
“Useful.”
“Remember where things came from.”
“Good.”
“Don’t pretend you understand what you don’t.”
“Good.”
“Credit people.”
“Yes.”
“Share benefits when appropriate.”
“Yes.”
“Listen when someone tells you you’ve crossed a boundary.”
Ama nodded.
“And?”
Eren thought.
“Receiving permission once doesn’t mean I have permission forever for everything adjacent to it.”
Ama smiled.
“Now you’re becoming less annoying.”
“High praise.”
After Ama died, Eren returned to the island.
Her family welcomed him.
Some liked him.
Some did not.
One cousin thought he had commercialized too much.
Another taught his books.
A third had never heard of him.
Eren found this healthy.
At Ama’s funeral, the family performed the breathing sequence Eren had once unknowingly taught as a relaxation exercise.
He recognized it immediately.
Slow inhale.
Pause.
Long exhale.
Again.
He did not join.
Not because he had been forbidden.
Nobody had forbidden him.
He simply stood quietly.
Ama’s daughter noticed.
She touched his arm.
“You can breathe.”
Eren smiled.
“I know.”
She understood what he meant.
Then she took his hand.
“Breathe.”
So he did.
Not as a teacher.
Not as an owner.
Not as the man whose name appeared on books.
As someone who had once been frightened in a storm and was shown a way home.
Breath.
Pause.
Return.
The practice belonged to a tradition.
It belonged to the people who carried it.
It belonged, in some ways, to Eren now too.
None of those truths erased the others.
And none of them required him to pretend a gift had arrived without a history.
Leave a Reply