Tales from the Universe
Moral Dilemma: If someone possesses a rare ability that could produce extraordinary beauty or benefit others, do they have an obligation to develop it—or does their life remain theirs even if choosing an ordinary life means the gift is lost?
Master Oren heard the mistake from the hallway.
He stopped walking.
Inside the practice room, someone was playing the old concert piano.
Poorly.
Very poorly.
Wrong tempo.
Uneven rhythm.
Several notes struck with the confidence of someone who had no idea they were incorrect.
Then came the mistake.
Oren opened the door.
A boy sat at the piano.
Perhaps eleven.
He froze.
“I’m sorry.”
Oren stared.
“Play that again.”
The boy looked terrified.
“I wasn’t supposed to touch it.”
“The last six notes.”
“I don’t know what I played.”
“Yes, you do.”
“No.”
“Play.”
The boy did.
Wrong.
Oren shook his head.
“Again.”
Wrong.
Again.
Then it happened.
One note changed.
Tiny.
Almost nothing.
Oren felt the hair on his arms rise.
“Again.”
The boy played.
There.
Again.
There.
Oren closed the door.
“What is your name?”
“Pell.”
“Who teaches you?”
“Nobody.”
Oren stared.
“That is offensive.”
Pell had no idea what he meant.
The mistake was not a mistake.
Pell had altered the chord.
Not randomly.
He had resolved a tension in a composition written three hundred years earlier.
A passage scholars had argued about for generations.
Oren had spent six years studying it.
Pell had heard it once and changed one note.
The change was better.
Oren hated him immediately.
Then loved him.
Then decided to teach him.
All within approximately thirty seconds.
Pell’s mother cleaned the conservatory.
She laughed when Oren approached her.
“My son?”
“Yes.”
“Music?”
“Yes.”
“He can’t sit still for dinner.”
“I don’t care.”
“He forgets his shoes.”
“I don’t care.”
“He once tried to dry a wet cat in the bread oven.”
Oren paused.
“Did the cat survive?”
“Yes.”
“Then I continue not to care.”
Lessons began.
Pell learned frighteningly quickly.
Things that took students months took him days.
Things that took years took months.
He heard patterns other people could not.
He could reproduce melodies after hearing them once.
Then alter them.
Improve them.
Break them apart.
Rebuild them.
At thirteen, Pell wrote a short piece that made Oren cry.
Oren did not tell him.
Teachers must maintain standards.
At fourteen, Pell said:
“I want to stop.”
Oren laughed.
Pell didn’t.
“Stop what?”
“Lessons.”
“For how long?”
“Forever.”
Oren stared.
“Why?”
“I don’t like them.”
“You don’t like scales.”
“No.”
“Everyone hates scales.”
“I don’t like piano.”
Oren felt something inside him refuse the sentence.
“You love piano.”
“No.”
“I have watched you play.”
“I like making things.”
“Yes.”
“Music is one thing.”
“Yes.”
“I like other things.”
“What things?”
Pell brightened.
“Boats.”
Oren nearly became ill.
“Boats.”
“Yes.”
“You want to abandon music for boats.”
“I like building them.”
“You are fourteen.”
“Yes.”
“You have no idea what you want.”
“Probably.”
“Exactly.”
Pell frowned.
“That doesn’t mean you do.”
Oren spoke to Pell’s mother.
She shrugged.
“If he wants boats, let him build boats.”
Oren stared at her.
“Do you understand what he can do?”
“Yes.”
“No.”
“He plays beautifully.”
“That is not what I mean.”
“Then what do you mean?”
Oren struggled.
“He may be one of the finest musical minds alive.”
Pell’s mother nodded.
“Good for him.”
Oren almost shouted.
He increased Pell’s lessons.
Four days a week.
Then five.
Competitions.
Performances.
Private instruction.
Pell resisted.
Oren interpreted resistance as immaturity.
This is an extremely useful interpretation when you want permission to ignore someone.
At fifteen, Pell won the Royal Young Composer’s Prize.
The audience stood.
Oren cried openly this time.
Pell bowed.
Backstage, Oren embraced him.
“You see?”
Pell stood stiffly.
“See what?”
“This.”
The applause was still audible.
“What you’re capable of.”
Pell looked toward the stage.
Then at Oren.
“I hated every minute.”
Oren released him.
“You don’t mean that.”
Pell laughed.
There was no humor in it.
“You always say that.”
“What?”
“Whenever I tell you something you don’t want to hear.”
Pell stopped attending lessons.
Oren went to his house.
Pell refused to come downstairs.
Oren shouted up the stairs.
“You are throwing away something people would kill to have!”
Pell shouted back:
“THEN GIVE IT TO THEM!”
Oren left furious.
On the walk home, he found a small pouch on the road.
Purple cloth.
Silver cord.
He picked it up.
Inside was shimmering powder.
A label read:
FANCY DUST
Underneath, in smaller writing:
Makes ordinary things seem extremely important.
Oren stared.
Then laughed despite himself.
He put the pouch in his pocket.
For years afterward he insisted it had nothing to do with what happened next.
Nobody believed him.
Oren arranged for Pell to perform before the Queen.
Without asking him.
This was, in Oren’s mind, decisive.
Nobody turned down the Queen.
Pell did.
The conservatory threatened to revoke his scholarship.
Pell shrugged.
His mother became worried.
“Maybe play once.”
Pell looked at her.
“You too?”
“No.”
She sat beside him.
“I just don’t want you to regret closing doors.”
Pell softened.
“I know.”
“Could you keep one open?”
“For how long?”
She had no answer.
Pell performed.
One last time.
The royal hall was full.
Oren stood backstage.
Pell walked onto the stage.
Sat.
Placed his hands on the keys.
Then stopped.
For nearly a minute.
The audience shifted.
Oren’s heart pounded.
Then Pell played.
Not the assigned composition.
Something new.
Simple.
Almost childish.
A melody repeated.
Changed.
Returned.
Changed again.
Oren recognized sounds.
Hammer against wood.
Saw through timber.
Water against a hull.
Rope pulled tight.
A boat being built.
Pell had turned the thing he wanted into music.
It was magnificent.
When he finished, the Queen stood.
Everyone followed.
Pell did not bow.
He closed the piano.
Then walked away.
Oren found him outside.
“You could be great.”
Pell looked at him.
“I know.”
That stopped Oren.
Not:
I don’t care.
Not:
You’re wrong.
Just:
“I know.”
Oren suddenly understood the shape of what he had done.
He had believed Pell did not understand the value of his gift.
Perhaps Pell understood perfectly.
Perhaps knowing something was valuable did not automatically mean surrendering your life to it.
“You could write music people remember for centuries.”
“Maybe.”
“And you’re going to build boats.”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
Pell smiled.
“I like boats.”
It remained an infuriating answer.
It was also complete.
Pell left the conservatory.
He became a boatbuilder.
A very good one.
Not legendary.
Good.
His boats floated.
Mostly.
One sank during testing.
Nobody died.
Pell considered this educational.
For years, Oren waited for regret.
Pell would return.
Surely.
At twenty.
Twenty-five.
Thirty.
The wasted genius would realize what he had abandoned.
Instead, Pell married.
Had children.
Built boats.
Played piano occasionally at taverns.
Badly, sometimes.
Deliberately, Oren suspected.
Then something strange happened.
Other students began leaving Oren.
Not many.
A violinist became a physician.
A composer became a baker.
One extraordinary singer decided she preferred teaching children.
Oren initially experienced each departure as a small death.
Then he began asking a different question.
Not:
“What could you become?”
But:
“What do you want this gift to be for?”
Some still chose greatness.
Oren worked them mercilessly.
With permission.
That distinction changed everything.
Decades later, Pell built Oren a small boat.
Oren was seventy-eight.
“I don’t sail.”
“You do now.”
“This seems unsafe.”
“It probably is.”
They took it onto the lake.
Oren sat rigidly.
Pell laughed.
“You taught me piano when I was eleven.”
“Yes.”
“You can learn this.”
“I was a better student.”
“You absolutely were not.”
In the middle of the lake, Pell handed Oren the tiller.
The old teacher held it badly.
The boat turned.
Wind caught the sail.
For a moment they moved quickly across the water.
Oren laughed.
Pell looked delighted.
“I still think you should have stayed with music,” Oren said.
Pell groaned.
“Forty years.”
“I said think.”
“Progress.”
“You were extraordinary.”
“I know.”
“You might have changed music.”
“Maybe.”
Oren looked across the lake.
“Doesn’t that bother you?”
Pell thought.
“Sometimes.”
Oren turned.
“Really?”
“Of course.”
Pell adjusted the sail.
“I wonder what would have happened.”
“Do you regret it?”
“Sometimes.”
Oren felt a terrible little satisfaction.
Then Pell continued.
“I also wonder what would have happened if I’d never built boats.”
The satisfaction disappeared.
“Do you regret that?”
“Sometimes.”
Oren frowned.
Pell smiled.
“You keep expecting the unlived life to stop existing just because I chose one.”
They sailed quietly.
After a while, Oren reached into his coat.
He still carried the pouch.
Old habit.
The label had nearly worn away.
FANCY DUST.
Pell stared.
“You still have that?”
“You know what this is?”
“Everyone knows what that is.”
“I found it the year you quit.”
Pell laughed so hard the boat tilted.
Oren grabbed the side.
“Stop!”
“You had Fancy Dust?”
“Apparently.”
“And you spent six months telling everyone my piano talent was the most important thing in the world?”
“It was extremely important.”
Pell laughed harder.
Oren considered throwing him overboard.
Eventually the boat steadied.
Oren looked at the pouch.
Then opened it.
The powder glittered.
He poured it into the lake.
Pell stopped laughing.
“Was that wise?”
“No idea.”
The dust spread across the surface.
For several seconds, the entire lake glittered absurdly.
Both men stared.
Then the wind scattered it.
Oren handed Pell the tiller.
“Your life was yours.”
Pell nodded.
“Yes.”
“I should have understood that sooner.”
“Yes.”
“You could pretend this is difficult for you to hear.”
“No.”
Oren smiled.
“Terrible student.”
“Terrible teacher.”
They sailed home.
Behind them, the last specks of Fancy Dust disappeared into perfectly ordinary water.
Leave a Reply